Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Collins: The Best Comedian

Mr. Collins although he expresses sexist notions about the nature of women specifically Elizabeth when he proposes to her, Austen mainly uses Collins as a tool of comic relief in her novel. Austen creates situations in which Collins evidently is making a fool of himself and every moral that he upholds. Harding in his article claims that Mr. Collins is a "caricature," expressing the idea that Collins is in one sense one-dimensional and is present for the readers enjoyment and analysis of the typical aristocratic male, which Collins truly is. If one were to state that Mr. Collins was a nightmare that observation would be false because in the novel Mr. Collins never truly interferes with the alteration of society and has little impact on most character's ideals. Hence due to Mr. Collins' egotistical behavior, the reader can perceive him as more of a funny character than a nightmare related character.

4 comments:

  1. Well i kind of agree with you Benzi, but Mr. Collins is also a nightmare as Harding calls him the "Comic Monster" for a reason. He is very funny indeed but what he creates for the Bennett's is putting a nightmore in perspective telling the Bennett's in a letter that Lydia will ruin your family name and might as well disown her. But other than that nice work Benzi. You got a gift my friend.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Benzi, but looking from Elizabeth's POV you must admit that Collins is a bit of a nightmare. He is using her for marriage while proposing to her, and talks down to her. He states how she might not understand his comment because of her inability to comprehend his intelligence. He is rude and a nightmare.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with you Benzi. I especially liked your point about Mr. Collins having very little impact on society and most of the people around him; therefore, he can't be a nightmare. Pretty good analysis overall.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Benzi, I think your argument is very strong because you were able to provide us, the audience, with evidence to back up your claims. I agreed with your view point as well in the sense that he is not a so called "nightmare" but is able to offer some comic relief. I also appreciated how you acknowledged the other side of the argument, it shows depth and development.

    ReplyDelete